Oh Fudge!

• Oh Fudge! •

It all began at my grandparents’ store, Ye Olde Sweet Shoppe, in Nashville, Indiana. My love of fudge was tucked away until it blossomed in 2020. I took a fudging break for two years…...but now I’m back!

Our Fudge Flavors

Chocolate

Rich and chocolatey milk chocolate fudge. Sold by the ½ lb. Gluten free.
Peanut Butter

Smooth and creamy peanut butter fudge made with JIF peanut butter. Sold by the ½ lb. Gluten free.
Peanut Butter Chocolate

Milk Chocolate Fudge paired with creamy peanut butter fudge, a perfect combo. Sold by the ½ lb.
Chocolate Walnut

Milk Chocolate fudge with walnut pieces throughout. Sold by the ½ lb.
Cookies & Cream

Vanilla Fudge with pieces of Oreo cookies throughout. Sold by the ½ lb.
Chocolate Mint

Milk Chocolate Fudge paired with peppermint flavored vanilla fudge, a refreshing combo. Sold by the ½ lb.
Chocolate Amaretto

Chocolate fudge paired with pink colored amaretto fudge..it tastes like a chocolate covered cherry. Sold by the ½ lb.
Salted Caramel Toffee

A fan favorite! Vanilla fudge with ripples of soft salted caramel then topped with crunchy toffee pieces and sea salt. Sold by the ½ lb.
Maple Pecan

Vanilla fudge flavored with maple flavoring with pecan pieces throughout. Sold by the ½ lb.
Birthday Cake

Vanilla fudge flavored like cake with rainbow sprinkles throughout, it’s a party in your mouth. Sold by the ½ lb.
Butterbeer

Butterscotch flavored vanilla fudge with butterscotch chips and miniature marshmallows. Sold by the ½ lb.
Rocky Road

Chocolate Fudge with miniature marshmallows and walnuts mixed throughout. Sold by the ½ lb.
Vanilla

As simple as it gets…plain vanilla fudge :) Sold by the ½ lb. Gluten free.